The Power of Myth

topic posted Thu, October 15, 2009 - 1:33 PM by  Unsubscribed
Share/Save/Bookmark
Advertisement
The Power of Myth by Joseph Campbell

I found the book to be very enlightening in regards to the worlds religions and myths.

Five out of Five
posted by:
Unsubscribed
Advertisement
Advertisement
  • Re: The Power of Myth

    Sun, October 18, 2009 - 4:07 AM
    picaro..what did you find that enlightened you..please tell me?
    I am interested in myth , dreams & symbolism, as various tracks to the unconscious. So wondering if this book is worth buying for myself?!
    • Re: The Power of Myth

      Sun, October 18, 2009 - 8:47 PM
      Lynne,

      This is a wonderful work though I might give it 4 stars out of 5. It has been a while since I have read it but what I loved about it was the universal themes he finds that run through myths across cultures and time. I think myths are, as you mention, pathways into our unconscious minds and derive a lot of their power from that. Before you buy the book you may simply borrow it from a library and see if you find it worth finishing and reading again.

      Speaking of myth you might check out my blog featuring my very favorite Halloween myth and ballad 'Tam Lin.' I'd be interested in your thoughts and opinion of it.
    • Unsu...
       

      Re: The Power of Myth

      Sun, October 18, 2009 - 9:37 PM
      "picaro..what did you find that enlightened you..please tell me?"

      I felt the book was enlightening in that it delved into a good many sensitive areas of religion myth and philosophy and in an unthreatening manner displyed many of the religions of the earth to be connected by common frame work that runs through all of them.

      I felt the book does well in presenting that there is a difference between reading and understanding myth and religious texts literally and metaphorically.

      I felt the book explained the purpose of myth in relation to society in simple terms and did well in explaining what is missing from our current society in regards to myth.

      I gave the book a high rating because while it is true that there are other more detailed works available for such studies this book covers these topics in a basic, simple manner that is un-threatening to someone that may be new to such concepts. For example it is not easy to explain the difference between "heaven on earth" and "heaven in the afterlife" to someone who is has been taught all there life one way or another is true and the other is false. This book covers this topic and a good many others in simple non-threatening conversational discourse between moyers and campbell very well in my opinion. In this way the book is a great standalone text for those that want to know a little more about religion, philosophy and myth. The book is also an excellent base for those that want to start somewhere in such studies and then move forward to more complex works since the book provides numerous topics to branch out further with specific study.
      Because of this books simplicity it may be of no value to college graduates of such studies who want to go further in their understanding of these topics. Also the book may be considered to run contrary to common dogma at times this book may appear as threatening to those that have dedicated there life to the dogma of an organized religion.

      I am interested in myth , dreams & symbolism, as various tracks to the unconscious. So wondering if this book is worth buying for myself?!

      I would say, yes the book would be worth reading for these topics so long as one uses it as part of a multiple book study that includes other such works by jung.

      This book is an extended version of a video series. If you are on netflix --->www.netflix.com/Movie/Jose...th/60030375
      • Unsu...
         

        Re: The Power of Myth

        Mon, October 19, 2009 - 1:07 AM
        Please allow me to revisit my last sentence.

        I would say, yes the book would be worth reading for the topics of "myth , dreams & symbolism, as various tracks to the unconscious" so long as one uses The Power of Myth as part of a multiple book study that includes more detailed books on each subject independently possibly including some works by Carl Jung.
        • Re: The Power of Myth

          Tue, October 20, 2009 - 3:02 AM
          Thanks Picaro & mark for your thoughts.
          Have you read `the mythic imagination` by stephen larsen?
          I was wondering whether it was along those lines. As carl jung is a part of this way of thinking bringing dreams/symbology/mythology together as part of the collective unconscious?
          • Unsu...
             

            Re: The Power of Myth

            Tue, October 20, 2009 - 10:33 AM
            I have not read "the mythic imagination" how ever judging by information I saw on Amazon my guess is that the book is personal psychology activities using Jungian concepts where as "the power of myth" is a scholarly myth and religion book.
          • Re: The Power of Myth

            Tue, October 20, 2009 - 6:46 PM
            Lynne, You are welcome. I haven't read Mythic Imagination. I find dreams/symbols/mythology all really fundamental to the human mind and always fresh and fascinating. I do not, however, believe in the collective unconscious. Jung was a complex man and earnestly tried to understand the mind and help his patients. Pursuing this exploration he had some brilliant insights but not all of them held up to further study.
            • Unsu...
               

              Re: The Power of Myth

              Tue, October 20, 2009 - 9:57 PM
              "I do not, however, believe in the collective unconscious..."

              As a general rule of thumb picaro believes...
              none of what is heard,
              half of what is seen.

              This general rule of thumb leads picaro to question literal theories about that which can neither be seen nor heard as only through myth and faith can such concepts be explained neither of which fall under the category of science. This leads picaro to his own literal theory about that which can neither be seen nor heard which is this: One human's reality is another human's dream.
              • Re: The Power of Myth

                Thu, October 22, 2009 - 9:59 AM
                Funny that these 'Universal Myths' seem to showcase an awful lot of European values.

                I would recommend this to fill in any gaps the honorable Mr. Campbell may have, um, forgotten:
                'The Hero With an African Face'
                by Clyde W. Ford
                www.amazon.com/Hero-Afric.../0613216997

                It's written by a chiropractor...but it's a step in the right direction...
                • Re: The Power of Myth

                  Thu, October 22, 2009 - 12:02 PM
                  You are, of course, correct; every culture is founded upon its myths and there are near innumerable cultures on this beautiful planet. They are not infinite in number but we do not yet know even if we know of all of them. We also each have our cultural biases. As W. B. Yeats wrote "...all could be known or shown were time but gone..."

                  Thank you for your comments and the web reference.
            • Re: The Power of Myth

              Thu, October 22, 2009 - 12:23 PM
              <<. I do not, however, believe in the collective unconscious.>>

              Mark I find it interesting that you accept the fundemental natures of dreams/symbology/mythology..yet cannot believe in the collective unconscious?
              I see the collective unconscious as partly the store area of the mind, that holds archetypes which reflect the experiences common to all.

              Jungs ideas about this concept cannot be proven because its untestable!
              Many scientists have accepted there is a collective unconscious though without testing because universally you see the same archetypes & themes rpeated irregardless of culture.
              & surely if we now accept that we all are structured through DNA..parts of your ancestors are there within you..who`s to say what they saw or felt is not there also?..so the symbols of their experiences are within..this is partly what the collective unconscious is about I feel.

Recent topics in "I just finished reading..."

Topic Author Replies Last Post
The Road-Cormac McCarthy Christina 24 Yesterday, 7:39 PM
Four Seasons in Rome by Anthony Doerr offlineJennifer 2 Yesterday, 6:23 PM
new free e-book Rocky 0 November 20, 2009
Lovely Bones HunnyDu 18 November 18, 2009