Literary Analysis...who else hates it?

topic posted Wed, September 9, 2009 - 2:27 PM by  Ben
Share/Save/Bookmark
Advertisement








Yeah yeah,

I know

it's just a hoop to jump through

and no one likes a complainer




....but that never stopped me before

...and really...
isn't it just another complicated game people play to seem smart when it's a totally useless skill except at dinner parties and if you teach it?

Or if you're a fiction writer?

And honestly, not to crush any dreams, but how many of those are there in the world?

And so it goes like this:
I'll *pretend* that I'm thinking this reeeally interesting (implausible) interpretation about this short story and then craft a paper (leaving out all the parts that contradict or don't fit) ...AS IF anyone will ever know WHAT the author REALLY meant because... he never said what the central idea or theme was himself! Maybe it doesn't even have one! Maybe it has ten! At any rate we won't discuss what significance the ideas have on our lives or etc just this make believe, unprovable, symbolism.

If life can't be summed up into a nice tidy little plot line why are we trying to do this with stories?
Why simplify thing?

haha,...I'm so flustered I'm babbling.

I'd much rather learn grammar any day of the week...at least I'll be using that once the class is over.

Now I can't even escape into a good book anymore without wondering about plot and theme. Yuck. It's like learning where hot dogs come from.

What a waste of energy.

Etc.


:P

Thanks for listening to me whine.
posted by:
Ben
offline Ben
Advertisement
Advertisement
  • Re: Literary Analysis...who else hates it?

    Fri, September 11, 2009 - 2:21 PM
    You hate literary analysis? Try what they do with poetry! I have rarey found anything as revolting as picking a lyrical barcque poem apart for pauses and meters and calling every element by it´s proper term and see if line 3 has a pause in the middle and the poem therefore fits the soandso genre.
    Worse and more astringent and sobering than someone asking right after sex:"Was it as good for you as it was for me?"
  • Re: Literary Analysis...who else hates it?

    Thu, September 17, 2009 - 5:08 PM
    I think the only problem with literary analysis is when people take it to seriously. The basic idea is that you examine a piece of writing more throoughly than you would during a single reading, and can therefore find deeper and varried meaning in the work. I agree all the proper terms, and trying to find what the author "really means" or some such nonsence is agravating, but the fact that it forces a more detailed look at the material is good.

    Also, most major schools of literary criticism agree that authorial intention is irrelevant.
    • Re: Literary Analysis...who else hates it?

      Thu, September 24, 2009 - 7:50 AM
      I'm starting to enjoy it.

      It's a lot of work though.
      Writing papers is sooo much more time consuming than Algebra or Biology.

      Also, it's a *little* harder to completely lose myself in a book or movie now.
      I keep wondering what the central idea is. Etc.
      • JM
        JM
        offline 96

        Re: Literary Analysis...who else hates it?

        Fri, October 2, 2009 - 3:08 PM
        Well, hell, half of the information you absorb is in text. What's the deal with learning how to read it like a (conscious, breathing, informed) adult?
        • Re: Literary Analysis...who else hates it?

          Fri, October 2, 2009 - 7:42 PM
          JM, at times literary analysis can be the same like going to the Uffizi and other galleries with my friend (who learned how to appreciate paintings in university). She keeps talking about composition and angles and centerpoints and such while I keep moaning in desperation:"But doesn't this painting spoil your mood completely? Isn't that one so depressing? That one over there is so overdone, the way they all look up into the sky with their suffering expressions...I think, some of these medieval Italians were suffering from sadistic perversion " etc.etc. and she just does not pick up on any of these things because she is analysing it all in a formalistic way without really feeling it.
          I know what Ben is saying.

Recent topics in "I just finished reading..."