Minority Report by Phillip k. Dick

topic posted Sat, April 26, 2008 - 7:52 PM by  Jennifer
Hi All... I just finished Minority Report, short read. I saw a little of the movie, will see the whole sometime bc I like Samantha Morton, not bc of Cruise. I'm starting to read sci-fi bc bc I have a writing idea in mind, more towards Star Trek. I'm also slowly reading Dick's "Puttering About in a small Land" - not sci-fi but still good in the opening, characterization, setting. That's my report for now!
Jennifer
posted by:
Jennifer
Phoenix
  • Re: Minority Report by Phillip k. Dick

    Sun, April 27, 2008 - 3:11 AM
    Phillip k. Dick is brilliant...His themes: Our darkest fears served back to us from possible futures and ours to avoid if we would only learn how..
    He has been a great inspiration to me. I also just learned elsewhere that he may have an Aquarian moon (?)
    I found the movie "Minority Report " quite intriguing. A tad chilly. Reading the book would appeal to me.
    I have a penchant for shorter books too. Thanks.
    She
    • Re: Minority Report by Phillip k. Dick

      Sun, April 27, 2008 - 4:48 PM
      Minority Report is a great read. The movie wasn't that bad. Im a big fan of Tom, but it was ok. I think all of DIck's stories are far better then the movies. The films tend to leave out the more twisted parts of the stories. Do Androids Dream Of Electric Sheep (Blade Runner) and We Can Remember it for You Wholesale (Total Recall) are perfect examples of this. A Scanner Darkly was one that stayed mostly true to the story.
      • Re: Minority Report by Phillip k. Dick

        Sun, April 27, 2008 - 5:56 PM
        Dick's imagination is so far beyond the sort of lazy story-telling that makes Hollywood blockbusters. And if he occasionally loses his plot, it's not like they don't.

        Do you think a credible movie could be made from VALIS? Maybe the bbc or sci-fi channel could do it.
        • Re: Minority Report by Phillip k. Dick

          Sun, April 27, 2008 - 6:51 PM
          Oh wow now that would be awesome if done right. I could see Sci-Fi doing a mini on it. Kinda like they did with the Dune books. I think the BBC might do it more justice if they werent hindered by budget. Less censorship is always a good thing.
          • Re: Minority Report by Phillip k. Dick

            Sun, April 27, 2008 - 6:57 PM
            I'd rather see it done low-budget with imagination and respect than high budget in the typical hollywood manner. Dick's ideas aren't really "Space Opera Grand Scale" so much as they are the creepy untold story of the universe. You could probably get away with a rather minimal amount of special effects. VALIS itself and the pink light and some of the melting into the empire. You'd probably have to spend more time debating just how litteral Kevin's cat is going to be than building any Kevin's cat prop.
        • Max
          Max
          offline 4

          Re: Minority Report by Phillip k. Dick

          Mon, April 28, 2008 - 2:24 AM
          The sci-fi channel? God no. HBO.
          • Re: Minority Report by Phillip k. Dick

            Mon, April 28, 2008 - 6:02 AM
            I'm also a fan of PKD's non sci-fi books, Confessions of a Crap Artist, Mary and the Giant, and The Transmigration of Timothy Archer might be my favorite PKD of all. Check 'em out if you can find them.
            • Re: Minority Report by Phillip k. Dick

              Mon, April 28, 2008 - 8:13 AM
              transmigration is pretty science fiction to me.
              • Re: Minority Report by Phillip k. Dick

                Tue, April 29, 2008 - 5:58 AM
                Okay, let's see, maybe I don't remember, but I don't think anything sci-fi happened in Transmigration...
                • Re: Minority Report by Phillip k. Dick

                  Tue, April 29, 2008 - 4:20 PM
                  Oh fuck. Brain fart. Confused with Stigmata.
                  • This is the maximum depth. Additional responses will not be threaded.

                    Re: Minority Report by Phillip k. Dick

                    Thu, May 1, 2008 - 2:16 PM
                    Well, it was about the famous priest who thinks he finds something in the desert and has a religious expereince, but we never see any of that, as the story is told second -hand through the daughter-in-laws narration. So it sort of skirts around the issue, and I think that's the point.
                    • Re: Minority Report by Phillip k. Dick

                      Thu, May 1, 2008 - 3:12 PM
                      Oh I read it, or at least tried. (Long time ago.) It was the Bishop Pike novel. Once I looked at Wikipedia it was a great, big "D'oh!" for me.
                      • Re: Minority Report by Phillip k. Dick

                        Fri, May 2, 2008 - 2:52 PM
                        I always thought PKD Dicks non-sci-fi books were HORRIBLE. you get all the poorly written pulpy melancholic sludge with none of the brilliant ideas. there are thousands of books you might want to read before you turn to that crap.

                        The *short story* Minority Report is much more political than the movie. spielberg & co watered it down and removed its teeth.

                        I actually liked the Blade runner adaptation. but its a page one rewrite. its inspired by Do Androids Dream of Electric Sheep rather than an actual adaptation. They could have slid by without giving Dick any cred, like Matrix, Truman Show, Eternal Sunshine of the Spotless Mind or other movies that smell like a dick ripoff.. er inspiration.

                        One of the most common features of dicks work is revealed at the end of Scanner Darkly. PKD was a speed freak who wrote most of his books tweaking. many feature speed psychosis style breaks with reality.
                        • Re: Minority Report by Phillip k. Dick

                          Sat, May 3, 2008 - 3:33 PM
                          I really like BladeaRunner as a film on its own merits actually, the brooding gothic atmosphere of it, the way they made the andoids tragic figures rather than evil ones.

                          I enjoyed the actual book in a diffrent way - it was a lot omore subtle. There was no room for the slushy romance Hollywood had to have in the film and there was no compromise: pathetic as thr androids were, they were evil: they lacked something.

                          I will have to read the Minoriy Report sotry again, that is all.

Recent topics in "I just finished reading..."

Topic Author Replies Last Post
I like the movie better milkyway 5 Today, 1:37 PM
Books that you live your life by? Ben 10 Today, 8:11 AM
dance of the dissident daughter Xtine 0 July 3, 2008
Vonnegut for Beginners? Taze 4 July 3, 2008